Re: H*lp, Not Handcuffs, for Homeless in Palo Alto, CA FWD

Judy Olsen (wholedamnpie@uswest.net)
Mon, 08 Mar 1999 19:05:49 -0800


This is great!  I'm saving it future use.  Thanks.
Judy O

Tom Boland wrote:

> ***********************************************************
> HOMELESS PEOPLE'S VIEWS, News, Alerts, Actions & Research
> 4,000+ ONLINE posts by or via homeless & ex-homeless people
> HOMELESS PEOPLE'S NETWORK http://aspin.asu.edu/hpn
> ***********************************************************
>
> http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/chronicle/archive/1999/02/15/MN3771
> 5.DTL&type=printable
> FWD  San Francisco Chronicle  February 15, 1999  Page A13
>
> PALO ALTO CHIEF ORDERS H*LP, NOT HANDCUFFS, FOR HOMELESS
>
> Carolyne Zinko, Chronicle Staff Writer
>
> Palo Alto's new police chief has made dealing with homeless people a top
> priority -- and unlike his predecessor, it's not all about arresting them.
>
> In the seven months since Pat Dwyer has been on the job, the police
> department has done a turnaround from the get-tough approach that emerged
> toward the end of former Chief Chris Durkin's tenure.
>
> Instead of focusing solely on citing the homeless for bad behavior, police
> have been given new marching orders. A two-page memorandum drafted by the
> chief calls for treating the homeless with more respect and helping them
> solve their problems.
>
> He has authorized a luggage cart exchange for any homeless person caught
> toting his or her possessions in a stolen grocery cart.
>
> He recently ordered the suspension of a program in which the mug shots of
> habitual drunks were posted in liquor stores to deter selling alcohol to
> them, because of concerns the program might be unconstitutional.
>
> As a further sign of his commitment, Dwyer is working on a $75,000 grant
> proposal for a new program for Palo Alto police -- an outreach team made up
> of officers, a nurse and a county mental health worker that would go out on
> the streets, searching for homeless people.
>
> The team will help the poor and needy assess their problems, get referrals
> to medical or mental health programs, and even give them a ride there if
> they need one, Dwyer said.
>
> No funding has been secured for the program.
>
> ``It's not against the law to be poor, homeless and have dirty clothes
> on,'' Dwyer said last week.
>
> His eight-point policy guideline notes in part that ``whenever possible, we
> will address problems associated with our homeless population by providing
> referrals to appropriate agencies and services.''
>
> It also notes that ``it will remain the policy of our department to
> scrupulously respect the rights and dignity of all people in our city,
> regardless of social status.''
>
> Advocates for the homeless applaud what they see as a shift in attitude.
>
> In 1997, the Palo Alto City Council banned sitting and lying on portions of
> upscale University Avenue, saying it was necessary for pedestrian safety.
> Homeless people cried foul, saying Palo Alto merely wanted to remove
> homeless people from public view.
>
> The council also directed police to get tougher on bad behavior downtown by
> stepping up patrols to cut down on public drinking, urinating on the
> streets and the like.
>
> The council recently voted to study a ban on panhandling from sidewalk and
> median strips, citing pedestrian and motorist safety concerns.
>
> Wynn Hauser, chair of the city's Human Rights Commission, called the
> chief's outreach proposal ``terrific.''
>
> ``It gives a whole different tenor to ways the city has approached the
> issue of homelessness. It's exactly right, focusing on prevention rather
> than just sweeping people out of the way,'' Hauser said. ``The city's
> response in the past has been one without the other -- the stick without
> the carrot.''
>
> At the Urban Ministry, the largest service organization for the poor in
> town, the Rev. Donna Smith-Power praised the new program.
>
> ``My hope is that it will help decriminalize the homeless,'' she said.
>
> She said it would be important for the team to work at night as well as
> during the day.
>
> ``There are a lot of people who don't come out during the day,'' she noted.
>
> But reaction was different from the homeless themselves, who say the city
> is still missing the boat.
>
> ``The best thing they could do is give us a place to shower,'' said Philip
> Crusch, 49, a former housepainter who has been homeless for four years.
>
> Crusch was pushing two shopping carts full of bottles to a recycling center
> near the Lucky grocery store in south Palo Alto on Friday.
>
> He said a nurse or a social worker would be of little value to him, since
> he is a veteran and goes to the Veteran's Affairs Hospital in Menlo Park or
> Palo Alto when he is ill.
>
> Another homeless man, who identified himself only as Roger, a 30-year-old
> who said he has worked as a carpenter, scoffed at the idea of an outreach
> team.
>
> ``I haven't seen anything to help us -- nothing but running us off and
> making us feel like we're yea tall,'' he said, motioning toward his knees.
> ``A nurse and a social worker? That's to make themselves feel better. What
> we need is a place to shower, wash our clothes, look for work and get a
> callback.''
>
> END FORWARD