[Hpn] The politics of giving

wtinker wtinker@metrocast.net
Wed, 24 Jul 2002 17:21:28 -0400


Boston Globe Online / Metro | Region / The politics of giving
By Eileen McNamara,
Globe Columnist, 7/24/2002
Skip the middle men, all of them.

Sister Margaret Leonard will take your money. She is not in the habit of
turning down donations to Project Hope, the
food-shelter/education-and-training program she runs for homeless families
in Dorchester.
Bridget Shaheen won't send your money back, either. She needs it to operate
Lazarus House, the emergency shelter/food pantry/soup kitchen/job training
program she directs in Lawrence.
And, count on my cousin Debbie Chausee to cash any check made payable to the
House of Hope, the family shelter and substance abuse program she operates
in Lowell. The former Sister of Notre Dame could use the help for the 18
families her program houses and feeds.
Your donations need not go begging if the clergy sex abuse scandal has
undermined your confidence in the integrity of the hierarchy of the Catholic
Church. There is no shortage of programs, with Catholic roots and ecumenical
hearts, that would be happy to take your money if you are more interested in
helping the poor than in making a political statement about power and its
sundry abuses by the man on Lake Street.

| Complete coverage |
 TODAY'S GLOBE

 Agency to accept lay group's funds
 Pope brings message to Toronto
 Law, teens travel to conference

OPINION
 McNamara: The politics of giving
 SPOTLIGHT BOOK

"Betrayal" delivers the full findings of the investigation into the church
sexual abuse scandal with new, never-before-disclosed details.
 Read an excerpt from the book
 Buy it  Amazon.com |  Globe Store
Reviews
 Boston Globe  |  Andrew Greeley
 N.Y. Times  |  R. Scott Appleby
  (registration required)
 PARISH AT THE CROSSROADS


Church pulls together in crisis
Shaken by the scandal, parishioners at St. Gerard's in Canton find strength
in their own congregation.
 Images of St. Gerard's parish
 How other churches are coping
 DOCUMENTS

Browse dozens of key documents obtained by the Globe during its
investigation of the abuse scandal.
 See complete list
 GLOBE MAGAZINE

Power to change the church
 Prelate Wilton Gregory is identified with reform more than any US Church
leader. Will he use his power to buck the system?
 Wills: The case against celibacy
 MESSAGE BOARDS

 April 10
How to address priest sex scandal?
 January 26
What do you think of Cardinal Law?
 GLOBE / WBZ-TV POLL

Catholics want Law to resign
 An April Globe poll found that 65 percent of local Catholics believe
Cardinal Law should resign.
 Complete poll results
 Earlier poll: February results
 GLOBE ARCHIVES

Find past articles on:
 John Geoghan
 Father Paul Shanley
 Cardinal Bernard Law
 Boston Archdiocese
Or run your own custom search:

Search for:

Search from:
 Today Yesterday Past 30 days Past 12 months Since 1979

 More search options
 CONTACT SPOTLIGHT

 If you have information on child abuse by priests, call
(617) 929-3208
Or leave a confidential message at this number
(617) 929-7483
The Spotlight Team e-mail address is spotlight@globe.com.


Cardinal Bernard F. Law this week is giving Voice of the Faithful an object
lesson in the limits of conciliation. You can't negotiate with a man who
won't come to the table. The archbishop of Boston says he does not want the
$10,000 raised for the poor by the polite folks in the grass-roots reform
movement who gathered almost 5,000 strong at the Hynes Convention Center
last Saturday. The price, having to answer to the laity for the use of that
money, is just too high for a man hanging onto power by a fingernail.
It's hard to say who is more naive: the discredited cardinal clinging to
moral authority he has already squandered or the earnest reformers
emphasizing their process at the expense of their results.
''Any setup that separates the role of the bishop from pastoral works is
something the church can't accept,'' said the cardinal's spokesman, the Rev.
Christopher J. Coyne, seemingly oblivious to the reality that Law himself
created the ''setup'' that separated him from pastoral work when he
knowingly assigned predatory child molesters as parish priests.
Delusional as such statements from the chancery are, the well-intentioned
laity could use a primer on the equally hard realities of running a
bare-bones antipoverty program. The Wellesley-based group has spent weeks
setting up an alternative funding mechanism for disenchanted Catholics who
did not want to contribute to the Cardinal's Appeal but did want to support
the mission of the church to assist the poor. Convoluted does not begin to
describe the process.
Donations to Voice of the Faithful's Voice of Compassion Fund would be
channeled to Boston charities through the nonprofit National Catholic
Community Foundation, which would send a quarterly check to the Boston
Archdiocese, specifying which charities should benefit and stipulating that
none of the money could be used for administrative or legal expenses.
Can you tell that the newly elected president of Voice of the Faithful is a
management professor at Boston University? The circuitous funding plan was a
nonconfrontational attempt to wrest some small amount of power from the
cardinal without causing offense. But, as the man said: If you're going to
make an omelet, you have to break some eggs.
There aren't a lot of management types working at Project Hope in
Dorchester, at Lazarus House in Lawrence, or at the House of Hope in Lowell.
Those on the front lines in the war against privation find that direct
action, in the form of negotiable currency, eases hunger and homelessness a
lot faster than even the most well-meaning deliberative process.
Checks can be made payable to: Project Hope, 45 Magnolia St., Dorchester MA
02125; Lazarus House, PO Box 408, Lawrence MA 01842; House of Hope, 812
Merrimack St., Lowell MA 01854.
Eileen McNamara is a Globe columnist.
This story ran on page B1 of the Boston Globe on 7/24/2002.
 Copyright 2002 Globe Newspaper Company.
[ Send this story to a friend | Easy-print version | Search archives ]


   Search the Globe
  Search for:
Today Yesterday Past 30 days Past 12 months Since 1979







 Copyright 2002 New York Times Company
| Advertise | Contact us | Privacy policy |



(none)